Opinion: “The Fallability of ‘Cause and Effect’”
In all facets of life, experts like to apply a ‘cause and effect’ framework to all events. In attempting to seek out the strand of logic that dictates all of the actions and reactions in the world, we can all subsequently sleep more comfortable at night knowing that we can explain what had been the unexplainable. A caused B because of C: pens down, hats off, work done.
With the recent events in London, people are anxious to share their wisdom and tell others the results of their messianic insights into human behaviour. An intellectual battle is currently taking place with experts, whether academically appointed or self-appointed, fighting it out in the public arena to design an explanation for the violence which trumps all others. Here is a brief summary of the battling explanations:
1) Cuts in spending on Youth Centres, partial scrapping of EMA, Tuition Fees Rising and high youth unemployment.
The youth are inflammed by the Government’s austerity package that has made them pay for the irresponsible actions of the financial sector. In a society that is already mired with inequality, the Government’s actions will widen gaping differences in the opportunities that are available for children of a poor background against those of a wealthier background. The Youth will influence the future success of the economy and thus the government’s actions are short-termed in nature and self-destructive. The youth are angry and this manifested itself in the actions that had taken place last week.
2) A broken/immoral/sick/(any other variation accepted) society.
It’s all about the youth culture. Teenagers today do not recognise, or certainly do not acknowledge, authority that tends to be embodied in parents, teachers and Police. There is a savage, animalistic streak running wild in our youth there is no longer a fear of consequences. In the same way they have no respect for other members of society, they also have no fear for private property as was illustrated in the looting. Ever since your grandparents were children, there’s seemingly been a steady erosion of values and morals.
3) New Labour
Labour’s extension of the benefit state created a dependency culture in which the poorest in society had all of their needs catered for without having to do an hour of work. Rather than fostering ambition, the Blair years did the opposite and let ambition fester. With the Tory cavalry having now stormed into office and slashing away at the welfare state, those individuals who had been paid to do nothing by the Government have awoken and aren’t happy. This is what caused the riots.
4) Mark Duggan
Dude got shot, people were angry about Police brutality and in the meanwhile stole some things. Simple.
5) Opportunistic
The opportunity came and people grabbed it. In the same way that when one is asked “Is this your £20?” and their knee-jerk reaction is to stutter a “Yes” along with a sorry explanation for why they had lost their money and how thankful they are for it being returned, the violence on the streets offered an open goal for people to take everything they ever wanted. This would explain the bags of merchandise from JD Sports.
6) Black People.
Starkey.
The common strand running through these explanations is the single-mindedness of those “experts” appearing at the vanguard of each of these. The debate on the causes is non-existant and is instead a back-and-forth of eachother’s opinions lacking in any evidence. These views are those from a vision that is distorted by vested interests and idealogies. Rather than addressing the fundamental problems in society that have made the youth angry, left them disillusioned with politics and not tempering to authority, we are all busily trying to pin-point the scenes witnessed in London to one event. Not only is this approach futile, it is also ultimately fruitless. These issues are complex and must be looked at and dealt with carefully.
If one really wants to solve this mess, it’s important not to seek out one ingredient in the mixing bowl and hold onto it as if it were the Holy Grail but instead analyse all of the ingredients that culminated in the truly dreadful scenes that were paraded in the news. A simple ‘Cause and Effect’ approach may provide comfort to ourselves but acting upon this will only make matters worse.
Yours Sincerely,
N

